This paper delves into the methodology employed in examining lean premixed turbulent flame fronts extracted from Planar Laser Induced Fluorescence (PLIF) images at elevated pressures. In such flow regimes, the PLIF signal suffers from significant collisional quenching, typically resulting in image data with low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). This poses severe difficulties for conventional flame front extraction algorithms based on intensity gradients and requires intense user intervention to yield acceptable results. In this work, we propose Convolutional Neural Network (CNN)-based Deep Learning (DL) models as an alternative to problem specific conventional methods. The pretrained DL models were fine-tuned, employing data augmentation, on a small annotated dataset including a variety of conditions between SNR ≈ 1.6 to 2.6 and subsequently evaluated. All DL models significantly outperformed the best-scoring conventional implementation both quantitatively and visually, while having similar inference times. IoU-scores and Recall values were found to be up to a factor ≈ 1.2 and ≈ 2.5 higher, respectively, with ≈ 1.15 times improved Precision. Small-scale structures were captured much better with fewer erroneous predictions, becoming particularly pronounced for the lower SNR data investigated. Moreover, by applying artificially modeled noise, it was shown that the range of image conditions in terms of SNR that can be reliably processed extends well beyond the images included in the training data, and satisfactory segmentation performances were found for SNR as low as ≈ 1.1. The presented DL-based flame front detection algorithm marks a methodology with significantly increased detection performance, while a similar computational effort for inference is achieved and the need for user-based parameter tuning is eliminated. It enables a very accurate extraction of instantaneous flame fronts in large image datasets where supervised processing is infeasible, unlocking unprecedented possibilities for the study of flame dynamics and instability mechanisms at industry-relevant conditions.