The transition to renewable energy sources is pivotal in addressing global climate change challenges, with rooftop solar photovoltaic (PV) systems playing a crucial role. For informed decision-making in energy policy, it is important to have a comprehensive understanding of both the economic and environmental performance of rooftop solar PV. This study provides a high-resolution analysis of existing rooftop solar PV systems in Switzerland by assessing the robustness of the potential estimation to properly derive the amount of electricity generated by individual systems, and subsequently quantify the levelized cost of electricity and life cycle greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions of electricity generation from PV and compare them with those of grid electricity supplies. Our results indicate substantial geographical variations between potential estimations and real-world installations, with notable underestimations of approximately 1.3 Gigawatt-peak, primarily for systems around 10 kWp in size, mainly due to the quality of input data and conservative estimation. The study finds that in many regions and for most of the installed capacity, electricity generated from rooftop PV systems is more economical than the grid electricity supply, mainly driven by factors including high electricity prices, larger installations and abundant solar irradiance. The GHG emissions assessment further emphasizes the importance of methodological choice, with stark contrasts between electricity certificate-based approaches and others that are based on the consumption mix. This study suggests the need for more accurate geographical potential estimations, enhanced support for small-scale rooftop PV systems, and more incentives to maximize the potential of their roof area for PV deployment. As Switzerland progresses towards its renewable energy goals, our research underscores the importance of informed policymaking based on a retrospective analysis of existing installations, essential for maximizing the potential and benefits of rooftop solar PV systems.