Alternatives to ecologically devastating deforestation land use change trajectories are needed to reduce the carbon footprint of oil palm (OP) plantations in the tropics. Although various land use change options have been proposed, so far, there are no empirical data on their long-term ecosystem carbon pools effects. Our results demonstrate that pasture-to-OP conversion in savanna regions does not change ecosystemcarbon storage, after 56 years in Colombia. Compared to rainforest conversion, this alternative land use change reduces net ecosystem carbon losses by 99.7 ± 9.6%. Soil organic carbon (SOC) decreased until 36 years after conversion, due to a fast decomposition of pasturederived carbon, counterbalancing the carbon gains in OP biomass. The recovery of topsoil carbon content, suggests that SOCstocks might partly recover during a third plantation cycle. Hence, greater OPsustainability can be achieved if its expansion is oriented toward pasture land.